Pilates vs. Barre: Which One is Better?

Barre vs. Pilates, what’s best for you? Find out more about each discipline and decide which one is right for you.
W

hen it comes to getting in shape, the possibilities are endless. From high-intensity aerobics to peaceful tai chi, each workout type has its own set of advantages, and they all boost your health and well-being in some manner. Recently spike has been seen in the popularity of both Pilates and Barre across America. Both are all low-impact disciplines that are good options for homework out as well as communal exercising. They can all help you to improve your flexibility, balance, and posture while also strengthening your muscles to help you avoid or recover from injuries. While these two training regimens have some parallels — for example, you can find yourself performing planks in both Barre and a Pilate’s class. The common aims of core connection and strength, as well as good alignment and posture, are the most striking similarities. Despite the many similarities, both Barre and Pilates have their characteristics. But the debates rage on - Barre vs. Pilates, what’s best for you? In this article, we will closely work upon the question through facts and research, so you can find out more about each discipline and decide which one is right for you.

Pilates vs. Barre: which one is more popular?

Both Pilates and Barre have been around for a long time now. But both experienced a renewed popularity, well, thanks to the COVID pandemic. The shutdown of gyms and fitness studios pushed people to look for alternate modes of exercising that can be done easily at home. Accessibility along with celebrity endorsements by some of the world’s most famous physiques like the Kardashian sisters renewed the interest of people in these simple workout exercises. But what is leading the race? Pilates or Barre?

According to a new study conducted by internet comparison firm ‘Compare the Market,’ Barre courses are the world's most-searched fitness class trend. In 2020, about 3.58 million people participated in Barre workouts. In 2020, about 3.58 million people participated in Barre workouts. According to Lauren George who is the co-owner of the Clemson Fitness Company, a boutique studio offering Barre classes in Clemson, “Our members love the Barre classes because everyone can feel successful doing the workout. Our members tell me they like Barre because it helps them to both feel stronger and move better.”

Just like Barre, Pilates has also grown extremely popular. According to the most current study from the Sporting Goods Manufacturers Association, Pilates is the nation's fastest-growing activity, with 8.6 million participants, up more than 450 percent since 2000. Pilates continues to increase, according to the 2010 IDEA Fitness Programs & Equipment Trends study (see page 22), while some other mind-body styles are dropping. Pilates, along with two near cousins, core training and functional fitness, was named one of the top ten trends for 2010 by the American College of Sports Medicine. According to Kristen King, founder of Sydney’s Fluidform Studios, the COVID lockdown has also added to the popularity of Pilates, “Over recent months the Pilates culture has grown, becoming prominent in the workout routines of so many and offered in most gyms and studios.” So, both Barre and Pilates have their targeted audience and popular base.

History of Barre and Pilates

Pilates was invented by Joseph Pilates (1880-1967), a physical trainer, invented for the rehabilitation of soldiers returning from war, and dancers like Martha Graham and George Balanchine were among the first Pilates patients (to strengthen their bodies and heal their aches and pains). The core ideas established by Joseph Pilates have been kept since the 1920s, and the Pilates remains loyal to its origins to this day, albeit with significant alterations.

Whereas Barre was invented by Lotte Berk, a London-based dancer who needed exercises to help strengthen her ailing back, in the late 1950s. Lydia Bach, a London student of Ms. Berk's, brought Barre to the United States in the early 1970s when she launched the Lotte Berk Method fitness studio in New York City. Jennifer Vaughan Maanavi, a member of the Lotte Berk class, couldn't bear the prospect of being without her favorite exercise regimen after the studio closed in 2005. So she went ahead and launched Physique 57 in Manhattan, which is credited with kicking off the boutique fitness studio craze and further popularized the format.

Is Pilates a good workout ?

The Pilates "method," as it is currently known, is an exercise routine that focuses on improving flexibility, strength, and body awareness. Pilates is a form of resistance exercise rather than aerobic (cardio) exercise, however, a deconditioned person's heart rate will undoubtedly rise. However, because it is more similar to weight lifting than running, riding, or other aerobic exercises, you can think of it as resistance exercise.

It has numerous benefits and its followers swear by them. Pilates can help you build longer and leaner muscles with less bulk and more freedom of movement. It can address postural problems and improve them. In one three-month study with 47 adults who practiced Pilates mat work one time per week for three months, the subjects reported that their posture felt improved at the end of the study. Other benefits are that it can help reduce the risk of injury and increase core strength, stability, and peripheral mobility. It can also :

  • Heighten body awareness
  • Balances strength and flexibility
  • Is low-impact and easy on the joints
  • Complements other methods of exercise
  • Improves balance, coordination, and circulation

Benefits of Barre workouts

Often times there are questions like - is Barre strength training? Is Barre a good workout ? Barre is a type of physical exercise that is usually done in a group setting at a gym or a specialized studio. The use of the ballet Barre and the incorporation of ballet-inspired motions set it apart from other group exercise activities. Resistance bands, yoga straps, exercise balls, and hand weights are occasionally used in addition to the Barre to integrate classical dance movements and positions with those borrowed from yoga and Pilates.

In Barre, the main focus is on small, pulsating movements with an emphasis on form, alignment, and core activation are hallmarks of Barre classes. In isometric workouts, participants hold their bodies immobile while engaging specific, targeted muscle groups. The lower body and core are the emphasis of Barre classes, which improve strength and flexibility from the ankles up through the calves, knees, thighs, and hips. Other benefits of Barre workout are :

  • Maximize muscle hypertrophy
  • Promote muscle intensity and volume
  • Increase muscle fiber cross-width
  • Increase the TUT of the involved muscle fibers
  • Improve endurance

Planning Pilates classes in 2022

Pilates classes involve a series of positions and body movements. During Pilates class, special attention is required to place your body into the various positions and hold it there. Modifications are often made on these positions to accommodate people of all abilities and fitness levels. Pilates classes can be either equipment-based or mat-based, with the latter simulating motions performed on machines like the Reformer and Cadillac.

You can use resistance bands or a Pilates ring in both classes (also known as a magic circle). Pilates focuses on both small and large muscle groups and uses your weight as resistance. Core strength, flexibility, and muscle tone will improve over time. Maximum results are achieved by working out at least 3 days a week. Pilates is not an aerobic exercise, depending on the type of class you attend, you can incorporate more heart-pounding moves into it. Typically, you'll proceed through a sequence of sculpting exercises that rely on core strength, such as 100s, leg lifts, planks, roll-ups.  It's best to combine it with some cardiovascular exercise regularly.

Planning Barre classes in 2022

A Barre studio is often a large mirrored space surrounded by ballet barres. However, just like Pilates, Barre can be done at home. A dancer's bar and a mat are utilized in the Barre fitness method. No prior dance experience is required for this hard and effective workout. The Barre method is suitable for people of all fitness levels and abilities. Resistance bands, sliders, ankle weights, free weights, and exercise balls can also be used. Barre workouts require minimal equipment

The Barre method relies on your body weight for resistance and emphasizes precise, careful movements that target specific muscle areas, particularly those that aren't used in other workouts. Muscles are worked until they are exhausted, then stretched for relief. Proper form, body alignment, and posture are emphasized, resulting in total core muscle strengthening and the look of a lean, aligned body.

Final question: Barre or Pilates

Consider the Barre method if you're unsure which workout method is best for you or if you think a combination of all three would be optimal. It integrates both yoga and Pilates practices, as well as its positive techniques.

Barre will help you develop and tone your muscles, enhance your core strength and posture, and give your body a sleek and toned appearance. Unlike Pilates, where results can take weeks or even months to appear, Barre participants can see results in as little as eight workouts. Another advantage of the Barre approach is the joyful tone and natural sense of community and camaraderie that comes with the Barre environment. SO, perhaps you can start with Barre and slowly move to Pilates as you get more accustomed because both have been said to show equal benefits.

If you are planning to open your gym, it better to start your journey with Bookee app. Bookee is the best fitness management software laced with industry best features and everything your fitness business might need.

Share this article

We’re here to help —
join Inside Bookee Newsletter

Get free education, tips, and inspiration to help you start and grow your fitness business.